⚖️ EA Comparison Tool
Compare 2-4 EAs side by side. The EA with the best value for each metric is highlighted.
📋 Select EAs to compare (3/4)
AIFW
★ AIFW AI Framework (XAUUSD M5, rule-engine defaults + AI override) MT5 backtest 2023–Aug 2026 (rules only, no AI, 0.01 lot): PF 1.77 / equity DD 4.6% / 228 trades / win rate 30.7%. At 5% compounding risk: PF 1.91, DD 51.4%. Earlier period 2018–2022: PF 1.42
DONCHIAN ENGINE
★ DONCHIAN ENGINE EA (100% free - USDJPY H1 Donchian breakout, hard stop-loss on every trade, ATR trailing stop, no grid, no martingale). 9.4 years of Dukascopy real ticks (2017-2026): PF 1.50 / rel.DD 10.8% (equity max DD 10.3%) / 631 trades / 34.5% win rate. Measured on the binary you download. Trend markets only - it does not work on ranging majors or gold.
BITCOIN COMET
★ BITCOIN COMET EA v1.44 (BTCUSD H4 trend, both directions + 3 extra engines) MT5 8yr (2018-2025, every-tick): PF 1.72 / rel.DD 31.2% (equity max DD 26.8%) / +12,165% / 775 trades / both halves profitable (PF 2.24/1.57)
| Metric | AIFW | DONCHIAN ENGINE | BITCOIN COMET |
|---|---|---|---|
| PF (Profit Factor)Gross profit ÷ gross loss. 1.5 or higher recommended | 🏆1.77 | 1.50 | 1.72 |
| Annual return (CAGR/simple %)Annual return (shown value calculated from 10-yr BT) | +6.2% | +10.9% | 🏆+82.4% |
| Max DDLargest account drawdown (lower is better) | 🏆4.60% | 10.80% | 31.20% |
Show 5 more metrics (win rate, trades, Calmar, projections)
| Metric | AIFW | DONCHIAN ENGINE | BITCOIN COMET |
|---|---|---|---|
| Win Rate | 30.7% | 34.5% | 🏆40.1% |
| Trades/YearNumber of trades per year | 228trades | 631trades | 🏆775trades |
| Calmar (annual ÷ DD)Risk-adjusted return (higher is better) | 1.35 | 1.01 | 🏆2.64 |
| 10-yr simple-interest projection (from $670) | $16,160 | $20,900 | 🏆$92,424 |
| 10-yr compound projection (from $670) | $18,190 | $28,100 | 🏆$1,226,481 |
💡 Comparison Summary
- PF (Profit Factor):AIFW (XAUUSD)
- Annual return (CAGR/simple %):BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)
- Max DD:AIFW (XAUUSD)
- Win Rate:BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)
- Trades/Year:BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)
- Calmar (annual ÷ DD):BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)
- 10-yr simple-interest projection (from $670):BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)
- 10-yr compound projection (from $670):BITCOIN COMET (BTCUSD)