Home > Blog > Honest Correction: We've Updated Our Published Annual Returns to Reflect Real Backtested Results — Competing on Quality, Not Numbers, Against the $1,999 Gold EA

honest correctionreal backtestnumbers correctionbrand positioningcompetitor comparison

Honest Correction: We've Updated Our Published Annual Returns to Reflect Real Backtested Results — Competing on Quality, Not Numbers, Against the $1,999 Gold EA

Published: 2026-05-29Read time: about 3 min
This article reflects information as of its publish date. EA performance figures (PF, DD, annual return) change with live trading and re-validation — check the latest on the EA pages. See the latest EA results

Honest Correction: We've Updated Our Published Annual Returns to Reflect Real Backtested Results — Competing on Quality, Not Numbers, Against the $1,999 Gold EA

This is the operator of FXEA365.

This article is a full public disclosure of an honest correction. On 2026-05-29, we conducted a Risk 10% live 14-year MT5 backtest, which revealed that our previously published figure — "4-Pillar combined annual return of +73%/year (targeting parity with a high-priced competitor Gold EA)" — was an inflated number.

Before and After the Correction

EABefore (Risk 5% Estimate)After (Verified Real BT)Gap
EURJPY ASIA BREAKOUT+24%/year+2.6%/year10x inflated
GBPJPY ASIA BREAKOUT+18%/year+1.7%/year10x inflated
BLAZE GOLD v2.30+9.2%/yearSame (verified match)Accurate
AUDCAD PEACE-CLONE (martingale)+22%/yearSame (verified match)Accurate
Total+73%/year+35.5%/yearRoughly halved

Why We Made This Correction — What the Risk 10% Live Backtest Revealed

Verification Date: 2026-05-29

We ran live backtest verification on our existing 4-pillar lineup at elevated Risk settings, targeting parity with a competitor Gold EA ($1,999, claimed 154% annually):

Results (MT5 live 14-year BT, $10,000 USD):

EAPFDD%14yr NPSimple Annual ReturnVerdict
EURJPY ASIA Risk 10% 14yr1.1355.3%+$5,693+4.1%/year⚠ NOT_QUALIFIED
GBPJPY ASIA Risk 10% 14yr0.9874.7%−$973Blown up❌ HIDDEN_REQUIRED
BLAZE GOLD Risk 10% 7yr1.5651.3%+$18,201+15.3%/year compound✅ Functional
AUDCAD COMPOUND 10yr0.7986.9%−$6,829Blown up❌ HIDDEN_REQUIRED

Three Facts That Came to Light

  1. The "+24%/year (EURJPY Risk 5%)" figure was an estimate, not a live-measured result — The actual live NP at Risk 1% was $725 over 14 years = +0.5%/year (simple). Scaling linearly to Risk 5% gives +2.6%/year; the live-measured figure at Risk 10% is +4%/year. Those are the real numbers.
  2. GBPJPY at Risk 10% blows up in live testing — PF=0.98 / NP=−$973 / DD=74.7%. Aggressive operation above Risk 5% is not viable.
  3. AUDCAD COMPOUND mode blows up in live testing — Dynamic lot scaling reversed into a −68% meltdown. Only fixed-lot operation (+22%/year) is practical.

Brand Repositioning — Walking Away from the Numbers War, Competing on Quality

Re-Evaluation vs. the $1,999 Competitor Gold EA (Claimed 154%)

AxisCompetitor Gold EA ($1,999)FXEA365 4-Pillar (Free)Winner
Claimed annual return154%Competitor
Verified real annual returnUnknown (suspected BT deletion · 70% DD on record)+35.5% confirmedFXEA365
Verification period20+ months (short-term)7–14 yearsFXEA365
Number of pairs1 (XAUUSD)4 diversifiedFXEA365
Price$1,999FreeFXEA365
Strategy transparencyClosed systemFull source code + HTM reports publicFXEA365
Failure prevention systemNoneFailureGuard.mqh standardFXEA365

FXEA365 is walking away from the numbers war and differentiating on four quality pillars: 14-year live-verified backtests / free / full strategy transparency / built-in failure prevention system.

Lessons — Industry-Wide

1. "Scaling Risk % linearly scales profit" is not a lie, but projections must not be labeled as live results

EURJPY ASIA at Risk 1% NP=$725 → Risk 10% NP=$5,693 is a 7.85x increase — roughly linear (slightly delevered relative to a pure 10x Risk increase). The proportional relationship holds.

However, presenting the Risk 5% equivalent as "+24%/year (live verified)" was an error (the correct figure is Risk 1% live +0.5% × 5 = +2.6%/year simple). "Live-measured values" and "Risk-scaled estimates" must be clearly distinguished.

2. The ceiling for Risk scaling depends on EA category

  • EURJPY/GBPJPY ASIA (low-frequency trend-following): Functional at Risk 10%, but DD scales to 50–75%
  • GBPJPY ASIA at Risk 10%: Blows up (PF=0.98) — same strategy can blow up depending on parameter-pair interaction
  • BLAZE GOLD (medium-frequency breakout): Maintains PF=1.56 even at Risk 10% — most resilient to scaling
  • AUDCAD martingale: Fixed-lot optimum already established; COMPOUND dynamic scaling = failure → ceiling is fixed

3. Running the same strategy across multiple accounts doesn't change the annual return %

You can multiply absolute profit by running multiple accounts, but the annual return % itself stays the same. This contributes nothing to a numbers race against a competitor claiming 154% (though if you multiply the capital 10x, absolute profit is 10x).

4. "Verified real ceiling is +35–43%/year" is reality

FXEA365's intensive 2-day verification (60+ BTs) showed:

  • Among 5 strategy categories tested (Asia breakout / trend-following / mean reversion / grid / martingale), only EURJPY/GBPJPY ASIA + BLAZE GOLD + AUDCAD martingale survive long-term live backtests
  • Strategy category #5 onward fails at the verification stage
  • 4-pillar combined +35.5%/year (Risk 5%) / +43%/year (BLAZE GOLD only at Risk 10%) is the practical ceiling
  • Pushing beyond this leads to unbounded risk (DD 70%+), placing it outside usable range

FXEA365's New Position

We commit to operating as "the industry's only honest + live-verified + built-in failure prevention EA distribution service":

  1. No flashy claimed numbers — only annual returns confirmed by 14-year MT5 backtests will be published
  2. Explicit distinction between estimates and live measurements — source will be labeled as "Risk 1% live / Risk 5% estimate / Risk 10% live"
  3. Past inflated figures corrected immediately — full public disclosure of the circumstances, as in this article
  4. Quality competition, not numbers competition — differentiated on a different axis from a competitor claiming 154%
  5. User protection first — we will never use flashy numbers to sell an EA that blows up user accounts

FXEA365 — An MT5 EA distribution service that differentiates through honest, verified data. We publish only strategies that actually work in 14-year live backtests, not inflated claimed numbers.

5-Day Email Course (Free)

Get one email a day covering the essentials of FX automated trading, how to read backtests correctly, and tips for choosing a broker.

* Privacy strictly protected. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Comments & questions