XMTrading Zero Account vs Standard Account
Contents
XMTrading Zero Account vs Standard Account — Which Is Better for EAs?
XMTrading offers several account types, but when it comes to running EAs the two most commonly compared are the Zero account and the Standard account. Which is better depends on your trading frequency and strategy. In this article, we calculate the actual costs and compare them head to head.
Basic Specifications
| Item | Standard Account | Zero Account |
|---|---|---|
| Spread | Variable (wider) | Ultra-low spread (from 0) |
| Commission | None | Yes ($10 round-turn per 1 lot) |
| Minimum deposit | $5 | $100 |
| Max leverage | Up to 1000x | Up to 500x |
| Bonuses | ◎ (generous) | ✗ (not eligible) |
| Stop level | 0 pips | 0 pips |
| Fractional spread display | ✗ | ◎ |
📧 Free 8-email course + subscriber-only pack of 13 MT5 indicators
Right after you sign up, you get a download link for a subscriber-only pack of our 13 MT5 indicators: compiled files (.ex5), source code and a setup guide. Then 8 emails on algo-trading essentials, reading backtests correctly and choosing a broker (one a day for the first 5 days, then 7, 14 and 30 days after signing up). You also get notified before each price rise of the versions sold on the MQL5 Market (launch pricing that steps up as copies sell). Our EAs are free on this site with a live account at a partner broker.
* Privacy strictly protected. You can unsubscribe at any time.
XAUUSD Spread — Observed Values (Reference)
| Account Type | Average Spread | During News Events |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | 25–40 pips | 50–200 pips |
| Zero | 3–8 pips | 10–30 pips |
The Zero account offers dramatically tighter spreads, but in exchange a $10 round-turn commission ($5 per side) is charged on every 1-lot trade.
What Trading Costs Actually Look Like
The core question is: what is the total of spread + commission?
Standard Account Cost
Cost = Spread × Lot size
Example: XAUUSD 0.1 lot, average spread 30 pips
Cost = 30 pips × $0.10/pip × 0.1 lot
= $0.30/trade
Zero Account Cost
Cost = Spread + Commission
Example: XAUUSD 0.1 lot, average spread 5 pips + $1.00 commission (round-turn)
Cost = 5 pips × $0.10/pip × 0.1 lot + $1.00
= $0.05 + $1.00 = $1.05/trade
Note that at 0.1 lot, the Zero account is actually more expensive.
Break-Even Lot Size
The Zero account only becomes cheaper when the cost of the spread difference exceeds the commission cost.
Spread difference: 25 pips (Standard 30 − Zero 5), Commission: $10 (round-turn per 1 lot)
Break-even = Commission ÷ (Spread difference × pip value)
= $10 ÷ (25 pips × $1.00/pip)
= 0.40 lot
At 0.40 lot or more per trade, the Zero account has a lower total cost.
Cost Comparison by Lot Size (XAUUSD, per trade)
| Lot | Standard | Zero | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.01 | $0.03 | $0.105 | Standard |
| 0.10 | $0.30 | $1.05 | Standard |
| 0.40 | $1.20 | $1.20 | Equal |
| 1.00 | $3.00 | $1.50 | Zero |
| 5.00 | $15.00 | $2.75 | Zero |
Recommended Account by EA Type
Cases Where the Standard Account Is the Better Fit
- EAs that trade small lots (0.01–0.3 lot) (account balance roughly $500–$3,000)
- Swing-style EAs with around 10–30 trades per month
- Beginners and small-capital starts (no commission calculation needed — simpler to manage)
- When you want to take advantage of XM bonuses
Cases Where the Zero Account Is the Better Fit
- Trades using larger lots (0.5 lot or more)
- Active EAs with 50+ trades per month
- Scalping-style EAs where spreads directly impact results
- Running with a reasonable capital base ($5,000 or more)
Recommended Account Type by EA Type
| EA Type | Typical Lot ($1,000 account) | Recommended Account |
|---|---|---|
| H1 swing type (e.g. DONCHIAN ENGINE, USDJPY H1) | 0.01–0.03 | Standard |
| M30 gold type (e.g. GOLD VIPER, XAUUSD M30) | 0.01–0.03 | Standard |
| Short-timeframe type, M15 or lower (e.g. XAUUSD M15) | 0.01–0.02 | Standard (for small capital) |
With an account around $1,000, the Standard account is more cost-efficient for every EA listed above.
Once your account grows to $10,000 or more and your lot size reaches 0.5 or above, consider switching to the Zero account.
How to Change Account Types
XMTrading allows you to hold multiple account types simultaneously under a single MyPage.
- Log in to your XMTrading MyPage
- Open an additional Zero account via "Open an Additional Account"
- Transfer funds and run both accounts in parallel for comparison testing
Running a Standard and a Zero account side by side and measuring the cost difference yourself is the most accurate approach.
Summary
- Small capital (~$3,000) and small lots: Standard account has lower costs
- Larger capital ($5,000+) and larger lots (0.5 lot+): Zero account is more advantageous
- The break-even point for XAUUSD is approximately 0.4 lot (assuming a 25-pip spread difference)
- Beginners should start with Standard and consider switching to Zero once they are comfortable
Keep in mind: the difference between account types matters far less than getting your EA settings right (SL, TP, RiskPercent). Confirm your EA is running stably on Standard before worrying about cost optimization.
FAQ
Q: Is the Micro account suitable for EAs?
XMTrading's Micro account defines 1 lot at 1/100 of the Standard unit, which allows for finer lot sizing even with very small capital. However, spreads tend to be slightly wider than the Standard account. It can be useful for functionality testing with less than $100, but for serious live operation the Standard or Zero account is more appropriate.
Q: Can I receive a welcome bonus with a Zero account?
XMTrading's Zero account is not eligible for the account opening bonus or deposit bonuses. If you want to take advantage of bonuses, choose the Standard account.
Q: Is there ever a 0-pip spread on the Zero account?
The Zero account can display "0.0 spread" at certain moments, but a commission is always charged separately. Think of it as total cost = spread + commission.
Q: How does it compare to Exness in terms of cost?
Exness's Raw Spread plan may have lower commissions than XM in some cases. We recommend comparing actual costs on the same currency pair and the same lot size. The most cost-effective broker will differ depending on the type of EA and your account balance, so no single answer applies universally.
Q: Can I run both an EA and discretionary trades on the same account?
Technically yes, but MagicNumber management becomes more complex. When discretionary positions (MagicNumber = 0) and EA positions are mixed, risk calculation gets complicated. It is recommended to open a dedicated EA account separately.
Related Pages
Related
📧 Free 8-email course + subscriber-only pack of 13 MT5 indicators
Right after you sign up, you get a download link for a subscriber-only pack of our 13 MT5 indicators: compiled files (.ex5), source code and a setup guide. Then 8 emails on algo-trading essentials, reading backtests correctly and choosing a broker (one a day for the first 5 days, then 7, 14 and 30 days after signing up). You also get notified before each price rise of the versions sold on the MQL5 Market (launch pricing that steps up as copies sell). Our EAs are free on this site with a live account at a partner broker.
* Privacy strictly protected. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Have a question about EAs or FX?
You can post it on the Nattzy trading forum (free sign-up). Questions beyond this article are welcome too — EA settings, choosing a broker and more.
Ask on Nattzy ↗